Figured I might as well...
And... yeah, damn.
There's a few good things to be said. The legs match well enough, it's not a perfect resemblance but it's fine. The arms work pretty well since Nautica is
supposed to have that kibble under her forearms so this actually works out pretty well.
... but then I realise why everything else felt off. The head is a bit too blocky and not round enough; the straighter shape and the stern expression make her seem like a much more serious-minded character like Elita-1 or Victorion or something rather than the awkward, fun-loving nerdy dork I very easily fell in love with. The fans being attached to the shoulders rather than sprouting out of her back make her way too wide to the point of silliness (it doesn't look like you can fold them back either which doesn't help, though even then it'd just look really dumb to have two big circles pushed off to the side like that), and... yup, that chest. Just doesn't work. At all.
Maybe Scourge
would have worked better.